QM BenchQuality engineering tools

CQI-9 heat treat self-assessment checklist

Prepare or track your annual CQI-9 self-assessment: select the heat treat processes in scope, rate each item by section, record evidence and actions, and export the findings as a PDF. How to use ↓

  • Free, no sign-up
  • Data stays in your browser
  • PDF report included
Click a rating again to clear it. NS and NIA open the action fields.

Processes in scope

select all that apply

Management responsibility and quality planning

15 items
  1. 1.1A named heat treat specialist is employed on site, with proven knowledge of the processes, the metallurgy and the CQI-9 requirements.

    Training records, CV, deputy for absences.

  2. 1.2The CQI-9 self-assessment is done at the interval the customer requires (typically once a year) by a qualified assessor, and its findings are tracked to closure.

    Last assessment, action list, assessor qualification.

  3. 1.3New parts and process changes go through advance quality planning: feasibility, part families, specifications and capacity are reviewed before acceptance.

  4. 1.4The heat treat process FMEA covers every step from receiving to shipping and is updated after problems, complaints and changes.

  5. 1.5A control plan exists for every process or part family and matches the FMEA, the process instructions and the shop floor.

  6. 1.6Customer and industry specifications are available in the current revision, reviewed, and their requirements are built into the process instructions.

    Specification list with revision and review date.

  7. 1.7Process instructions (recipes) define every parameter with its tolerance for each part or part family, and recipe changes are approved and recorded.

  8. 1.8Product and process changes are notified to the customer and approved before they are introduced, where the customer requires it.

  9. 1.9Operators, laboratory staff and maintenance staff are trained and qualified for their tasks, with records and a qualification matrix.

  10. 1.10Nonconforming product and process deviations are segregated, dispositioned and solved with a root cause and verified corrective action.

  11. 1.11Heat treat records (load charts, parameters, test results) are kept for the required retention period and can be found by load or lot.

  12. 1.12Reaction plans exist for out-of-control conditions, alarms and equipment failure, including what happens to the parts in the furnace.

  13. 1.13Measuring and test equipment is calibrated, and measurement system analysis is done for the gauges named in the control plan.

  14. 1.14External laboratories and outsourced heat treat steps are approved and monitored, with the accreditation the customer requires.

  15. 1.15Internal audits, job audits and management review cover heat treat performance, and the results drive improvement actions.

Floor and material handling responsibility

10 items
  1. 2.1Incoming parts are checked on receipt against the order and the shipping documents: part number, quantity, condition and material.

  2. 2.2Every container shows its status at every step: waiting, in process, processed, on hold or rejected.

  3. 2.3Loading follows a defined method for each part: fixture, orientation, load weight and spacing, with a picture or sketch at the workplace.

  4. 2.4Lots are never mixed: one lot per load or a clear separation, and a rule for parts that fall from the load or fixture.

  5. 2.5Handling, fixtures and washing do not damage parts (nicks, distortion, residues) and wash and rinse media are maintained.

  6. 2.6Parts affected by an alarm, power loss or interruption are identified and held until a qualified person decides on them.

  7. 2.7Reprocessing (re-heat treat, re-temper) is done only by an approved procedure, with customer approval where required, and is recorded.

  8. 2.8Each shipped lot can be traced back to the furnace, the load, the recipe, the recorded parameters and the test results.

  9. 2.9Finished parts are packed, labelled and stored so that mix-ups, corrosion and damage are prevented.

  10. 2.10The work area is clean and orderly, with defined places for material and no unidentified parts.

Equipment

12 items
  1. 3.1Thermocouples, sensors and temperature instruments meet the type, accuracy and calibration requirements, with calibration certificates.

  2. 3.2Thermocouples are replaced or recalibrated at defined intervals, and their usage is recorded.

  3. 3.3System accuracy tests (SAT) are done at the required frequency and the results are within tolerance.

    Compare frequency in the procedure with the process table and the customer specification.

  4. 3.4Temperature uniformity surveys (TUS) are done at installation, after major repairs and at the required frequency, covering the qualified operating range.

  5. 3.5Critical parameters (temperature, time, atmosphere, quench) are recorded continuously and an alarm alerts the operator when they leave the limits.

  6. 3.6Furnace atmosphere control is verified, for example carbon potential by shim stock or another independent check, and the probes are maintained.

  7. 3.7Quench systems are monitored (temperature, agitation, level) and the quenchant is analysed at defined intervals, for example by cooling curve.

  8. 3.8Induction equipment monitors energy or power, time or scan speed, quench flow and concentration; coils are identified and checked.

  9. 3.9A preventive maintenance plan covers furnaces, quench systems, generators and handling equipment, with records and critical spare parts.

  10. 3.10Equipment is requalified (for example with a new TUS) after rebuilds, relocations or major repairs before production restarts.

  11. 3.11Hardness testers and other laboratory equipment are calibrated and verified with reference blocks before use.

  12. 3.12Recipes and control system settings are protected against unauthorised changes, for example by passwords and change records.

Process tables

7 items
  1. 4.1Every heat treat process in use is identified and the matching CQI-9 process table is applied to it.

  2. 4.2Every process parameter the table lists is monitored, at least at the frequency the table gives.

  3. 4.3Pyrometry intervals (thermocouples, SAT, TUS) follow the table and the furnace class, and the stricter value is used where the customer specification differs.

  4. 4.4Product tests (surface and core hardness, case or effective depth, microstructure, decarburisation as applicable) are done at the required frequency with a defined method and sample size.

  5. 4.5Test locations and test pieces represent the load, and the method for test coupons is defined where parts cannot be tested directly.

  6. 4.6Atmosphere, quenchant and other process media are checked at the frequencies the table gives.

  7. 4.7Results outside the table or specification trigger the reaction plan, and the decision on the parts is recorded.

No ratings yet

Rate the items on the left or load the sample.

  1. 1Enter or paste dataor click Load sample
  2. 2Read the verdictcharts and key figures
  3. 3Download the PDFwith your logo

How to use the checklist

  1. Select the processes in scope. Each heat treat process you run has its own process table in the CQI-9 manual. Section 4 of this checklist asks whether you meet them.
  2. Rate every item with evidence. Satisfactory only when you can show a record, a procedure or the shop floor practice. Use N/A with a reason, for example no induction hardening.
  3. Add the action for each gap. Not satisfactory and needs immediate action open fields for the corrective action, owner and due date. The findings list on the right shows which actions are still missing.
  4. Do the job audit separately. Follow one real order from receipt to shipment through the records and compare it with the customer specification and the process table. Record what you find against the items here.
  5. Export the PDF with the report header (site, customer, CQI-9 edition, assessor) and keep it with the evidence for the customer and the IATF auditor.

The four sections

  • Management responsibility and quality planning: heat treat specialist, quality planning, FMEA and control plan, specifications, change control, training, nonconforming product, records.
  • Floor and material handling responsibility: receiving, identification and status, loading, lot integrity, suspect product after interruptions, reprocessing, traceability, packing.
  • Equipment: thermocouples and instruments, system accuracy tests, temperature uniformity surveys, process monitoring and alarms, atmosphere and quench control, maintenance, laboratory equipment.
  • Process tables: monitoring and test frequencies for each heat treat process, pyrometry intervals by furnace class, product tests and the reaction when a result is outside the limits.

Typical findings

  • Temperature uniformity survey or system accuracy test overdue, or done on a smaller work zone than the one used in production.
  • Process FMEA and control plan not updated after a change of quenchant, furnace or recipe.
  • No rule for parts that fall from fixtures or baskets, or for parts in the furnace during a power loss.
  • Hardness tester verified with a reference block that does not cover the hardness range tested.
  • Customer specification revision not reviewed, so a stricter test frequency is missed.

Close repeated findings with an 8D report, and use the process capability tool for hardness and case depth data. For what CQI assessments are, who requires them and how they relate to IATF 16949, see the CQI special process hub.

The checklist items are our own short wording for preparing a self-assessment. They do not reproduce or replace the AIAG CQI-9 manual, which defines the official requirements and process tables. QM Bench is not affiliated with AIAG.

Frequently asked questions

What is CQI-9?

CQI-9 is the AIAG Heat Treat System Assessment. It checks whether a heat treating operation, in-house or commercial, controls its management system, material handling, equipment and pyrometry, and meets the monitoring and test frequencies in the process tables for each heat treat process.

Who has to do a CQI-9 assessment?

Every site that heat treats automotive parts for a customer that requires it in its customer-specific requirements, including commercial heat treaters working for automotive suppliers. The supplier that buys heat treatment must flow the requirement down and check that it is met.

How often is CQI-9 required?

Typically once a year as a self-assessment, and again after major changes such as new furnaces, a new location or a new process. The customer-specific requirements decide the exact interval and the edition to use.

What do S, NS and NIA mean?

Satisfactory means the requirement is met with evidence. Not satisfactory means a gap that needs a corrective action with owner and due date. Needs immediate action is a gap that can put product at risk now, such as an overdue temperature survey or a missing alarm, and needs containment before the fix.

What is the difference between SAT and TUS?

A system accuracy test (SAT) checks that the whole temperature measuring chain, sensor plus instrument, reads correctly against a reference. A temperature uniformity survey (TUS) checks that the temperature is the same, within tolerance, everywhere in the qualified work zone of the furnace.

Does this checklist replace the AIAG manual?

No. The items are short paraphrases written to help you prepare and track a self-assessment. The official assessment must follow the current AIAG CQI-9 manual and your customers’ requirements, including the job audit and the process table requirements in full.