QM BenchQuality engineering tools

IS / IS NOT analysis explained, with a Kepner-Tregoe example

How to describe a problem with IS / IS NOT: what, where, when and how big, distinctions and changes, testing possible causes against the facts, and a worked 8D D2 example.

Ľubomír Blažek
Process quality team leader, automotive · updated 2026-11-14

Try it while you read

Open the free IS / IS NOT Analysis tool and click Load sample: it reproduces the case study below.

Open the tool

Theory: the cause lies in the difference

IS / IS NOT comes from the Kepner-Tregoe problem analysis. For every dimension of the problem (what, where, when, how big) the team records what is affected and what could be affected but is not. The distinctions between the two columns, and the changes that happened around them, point to the cause.

Key point

A real cause must explain every IS and every IS NOT. A cause that explains only some of the facts is either wrong or only part of the story.

Step by step

  1. Write a short problem statement: object and defect.
  2. Fill in IS and IS NOT for what, where, when and extent with facts, not opinions.
  3. For each pair note what is distinctive about the IS side and what changed.
  4. Enter possible causes and test each against all facts; the tool ranks them.
  5. Verify the most probable cause by switching it on and off before acting.

Case study: broken latch clips

The latch clip of a 6-pole PA66 connector housing breaks at the customer’s assembly line (the Load sample). The fracture is smooth and brittle.

  • IS: 6-pole housings moulded from 14 October. IS NOT: the 4-pole housing from the same machine, or 6-pole parts moulded earlier.
  • Distinction: the 6-pole housing is fed from dryer D2, the 4-pole from dryer D1. Change: the D2 set point was raised from 80 to 120 °C after maintenance on 13 October.
  • More breaks after weekend stops, when the material stays longest in the hot dryer.

Over-drying explains every IS and every IS NOT; a mould or handling problem would not spare the 4-pole housing. The set point is reset, retained parts are checked by a melt flow test, and the dryer setting goes into the control plan. The full problem solving continues in the 8D report.

Common mistakes

  • Leaving the IS NOT column empty.
  • Writing assumptions instead of checked facts.
  • Stopping at the first cause that fits some facts.

Frequently asked questions

Is IS / IS NOT the same as 5W2H?

They complement each other. 5W2H describes the problem; IS / IS NOT adds the comparison with what is not affected, which is where the cause hides.

When does IS / IS NOT not help?

When the process has never worked, because then there is no change to find. Use a capability study or a DOE instead.