Try it while you read
Open the free True Position Calculator (GD&T) tool and click Load sample: it reproduces the case study below.
Theory: position, bonus and virtual condition
The position tolerance is a cylindrical zone of diameter t around the true position. The measured deviation is a radius, so it is doubled before comparing with the tolerance.
With an MMC modifier, the bonus is how far the actual mating size has moved from the maximum material size: a larger hole or a smaller pin fits more easily, so it may be further off position. With LMC it works from the least material size, to protect a minimum wall.
Key point
Step by step
- Enter each hole or pin with its position tolerance, modifier and size limits.
- Enter dX and dY from the CMM report in the datum reference frame of the drawing.
- Enter the actual mating size for MMC, or the actual minimum material size for LMC.
- Read the result per feature, the plot and whether the pattern shows a common shift.
Case study: four holes and two pins
A bracket has four holes Ø10 +0.2/0 with position Ø0.1 at MMC and two pins Ø8 −0.1/0 with position Ø0.05 at MMC (the Load sample).
- Hole 2: dX 0.06, dY 0.08, position Ø0.20, twice the stated tolerance. Its actual size 10.12 gives 0.12 bonus, so Ø0.22 is allowed: accepted.
- Hole 3: position Ø0.17 but actual size 10.03, only 0.03 bonus: rejected.
- The plot shows whether the deviations scatter or all lean the same way; a common lean points to the fixture or program zero rather than to single holes.
Without the MMC bonus, hole 2 would have been rejected too. With position values of many parts, check capability in the process capability tool.
Common mistakes
- Comparing the radial deviation with the diametral tolerance.
- Using a two-point diameter instead of the actual mating size.
- Adding datum feature shift as a bonus to every feature.
Frequently asked questions
Can I use a square tolerance zone instead?
Only if the drawing specifies one. A diametral zone allows 57 % more area than the inscribed square, so converting a position tolerance into ± coordinates rejects good parts.
Why does the CMM report a different value?
Check the datum alignment, the fitting method for the feature (least squares or maximum inscribed), and whether the CMM already adds the bonus. Recalculate with the same rules on both sides.