Pugh matrix online
Compare solution options or design concepts with a datum, usually the current process, on weighted criteria. Click better, same or worse in every cell and see the sums, the weighted score and the ranking of the options at once.
The verdict names the strongest option and its weak points, the criteria where it is worse than the datum, so the team can borrow ideas from other options and run a second round.
Worked example: Pugh Matrix
- 01Criteria6, weightedflatness, cost, time, risk …
- 02Score+ / S / −against the datum
- 03Sum+15floating clamp
- 04Nextpilotprove with data
01Method
Each score is +1 (better), 0 (same) or −1 (worse), or −2 to +2 on the wider scale. Weighted score = Σ score × criterion weight. Options are ranked by weighted score, then by the plain net score, then by fewer minuses.
PDF report in one click
Export a landscape PDF with the decision, the datum, the full matrix with sums and ranking, and the chart.
Private: runs in your browser
All data stays in your browser. Nothing is uploaded and no account is needed.
How to use a Pugh matrix
- State the decision and choose the datum, usually today’s process.
- Agree the criteria with the team, from the CTQs, cost, time and risk, and give them weights.
- List the options, including combinations and simple ones.
- Score each option against the datum per criterion: + better, S same, − worse.
- Read the sums, then improve the leading option where it scores −, and repeat with it as the new datum.
Worked example
A Green Belt team chooses a fix for leak test failures on fixture 2. Against today’s repaired clamp they compare a floating clamp with a torque tool, re-machining the fixture, a 100 % flatness check and simply lowering the clamping pressure. The floating clamp wins with a weighted score of +15: better on flatness, risk, operation and robustness, the same on cost and time. Lowering the pressure is cheap and quick but risks other characteristics; the 100 % check only sorts and adds cost.
Use the CTQs from the CTQ tree as criteria, check the risks of the chosen option with the FMEA, and prove its effect in a pilot with a hypothesis test. The full roadmap is in DMAIC step by step.
Frequently asked questions
›What is a Pugh matrix?
A decision matrix developed by Stuart Pugh for concept selection. Each option is compared with one reference, the datum, criterion by criterion: better (+), same (S) or worse (−). The sums show which options beat the datum and where each one is weak.
›What should I use as the datum?
The current process or product, or the best-known concept. Everything is judged relative to it, so pick something the whole team knows well.
›Should I weight the criteria?
Weights help when criteria are clearly not equally important, for example safety against cosmetics. Keep the scale simple (1 to 5) and agree the weights before scoring, otherwise people adjust them to favour their option.
›Is the option with the highest score automatically the answer?
Not necessarily. The matrix is a structured discussion. Look at the weak points of the leading option and borrow ideas from others to fix them, then run a second round with the improved concept as the new datum. Confirm the final choice with data in a pilot.